Myths versus facts
What people assume, and what the record says
The tidiest Bonfire Night stories are often almost right, and a little less particular than the official pages.

- Myth: Guy Fawkes was the mastermind.
- Fact: English Heritage and UK Parliament both name Robert Catesby as the mastermind. Fawkes was, in Parliament’s wording, “recruited as the gunpowder expert.” [source] [source]
- Myth: He was caught, in every official account, on the 5th with the gunpowder in his hands.
- Fact: Parliament’s Journal page puts Knyvett and Doubleday on the evening of 4 November, finding “Guy Fawkes and his gunpowder.” English Heritage puts firewood on the 4th and gunpowder in the early hours of the 5th. A people page dates the basement arrest to 5 November. All three are official, and they are not identical. [source] [source] [source]
- Myth: We know for certain that Tresham wrote the Monteagle letter.
- Fact: Parliament says “it may have been Tresham.” English Heritage does not treat the author as certain. [source] [source]
- Myth: The Guy on the fire has always been Guy Fawkes.
- Fact: English Heritage says the 1673 effigy was “initially in the form of the Pope,” and that the familiar Guy Fawkes figure arrived in the 1800s. [source]
- Myth: Bonfire Night is only a folk custom, with no official beginning.
- Fact: Parliament names the Thanksgiving Act of 1606, which made services and sermons on 5 November an annual event. [source]
- Myth: Every Bonfire Night photograph on this site was taken on 5 November.
- Fact: The Camberwell and Alexandra Palace bonfires were photographed on 4 November. The captions say so.
- Myth: A file titled “Bondfire” is a picture of a bonfire.
- Fact: CGP Grey’s Battersea Park photographs of 5 November 2005 are fireworks. The official description of one file is “Fireworks, Battersea Park,” and both pictures on this site are captioned as fireworks. [source]
- Myth: The palace in a modern riverside photograph is the building of 1605.
- Fact: The 1829 Deeble print shows the old Parliament House, years before its later destruction. The 2025 and 2026 photographs are of the later palace. [source]
- Myth: The Ashmolean lantern is officially, without qualification, Fawkes’s lantern.
- Fact: The file used here describes it as “what is reported to be Guy Fawkes Lantern.” That wording is kept. [source]
- Myth: Official pages still present Bonfire Night as an anti-Catholic festival.
- Fact: English Heritage says today’s celebrations “are stripped of their anti-Catholic sentiment.” [source]
- Myth: The plotters were a small band of gentlemen only.
- Fact: English Heritage says they were predominantly gentry, but that Catesby’s servant, Thomas Bates, took the number to thirteen. [source]
- Myth: There is no official figure for how much gunpowder was in the vault.
- Fact: Both English Heritage and the Commons Journal page say 36 barrels. [source] [source]
Keep exploring
Enjoyed Bonfire Night?
No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next traditions site get built.